According to forum posts, car rental options on St. John include Virgin Islands Auto Rental, highly praised for its service and quality of vehicles. Other mentioned companies are STJ Rentals, Conrad Suttons, Courtesy, and Penns, now known as Mr. Pipers. For immediate needs, it's advised to secure a vehicle as soon as possible due to high demand, especially during peak travel times.

Travelers have called out that securing a rental car can be challenging, with companies often booked far in advance. It's recommended to frequently check company websites for availability. Some users suggested looking into roadside assistance options as they vary between companies, with some charging additional fees.

For those needing more immediate rental options or different vehicle types, it's suggested to also consider rental companies on St. Thomas, as they often have additional availability, and the vehicle can be transported between islands.

According to forum posts, many travelers prefer staying in Cruz Bay due to its proximity to amenities and activities. Cruz Bay offers easy access to restaurants and shops, and places like Gallows Point Resort provide beachfront access with snorkeling opportunities.

For families, areas like Grande Bay and Gallows Point in Cruz Bay are popular. These locations are praised for their proximity to the ferry and local facilities, making them convenient for families traveling with children.

Some travelers have recommended more secluded areas for those seeking peace and quiet. The south shore and areas like Coral Bay or the East End are mentioned for their quieter settings, offering a respite from the more tourist-heavy Cruz Bay.

For special occasions like anniversaries, some forum users have suggested private villas or unique stays like Gibney Cottages on Hawksnest Bay, known for their privacy and direct beach access, though they can be more expensive.

Many travelers recommend Low Key Watersports in Cruz Bay for snorkel gear rentals, highlighting their quality and the option to pre-register for a 15% discount. Beach Bum, also highly recommended, provides gear and is known for excellent customer service.

For those staying near Coral Bay, Busy Bee Watersports is praised for having the best quality gear and service. Just Beach in Mongoose Junction is another spot where you can rent snorkel gear for the week. Options vary in terms of quality and services offered, so preferences may depend on specific needs and locations within St. John.

Some travelers mentioned that a passport card is sufficient for boat trips from St. John to the British Virgin Islands (BVI), specifically when traveling by boat.

According to forum posts, several charter services such as Stormy Pirates, Palm Tree Charters, Island Roots, Cruz Bay Watersports, Bad Kitty, and Nates Custom Charters are mentioned as options for day trips to BVI. These services vary in their offerings, from private to shared charters.

Travelers have called out the fluctuating availability of these trips, particularly due to COVID-19 restrictions and the process of obtaining necessary permits. However, some posts indicate that services to popular destinations like The Baths, White Bay, and Norman Island are operational, with private charters being highly recommended for tailored experiences.

For those looking for different options, BVI-based charter companies like Island Time Charters and Chillout Charters also operate and can pick up passengers from St. John.

Some travelers mentioned that Starfish Market is a consistent option for purchasing lobster, which can be enjoyed if you prefer to cook at your villa. Additionally, fresh lobster can occasionally be bought from local fishermen at docks, particularly across from the clinic area on St. John, though there isn’t a designated fish market.

For dining out, while specific restaurants serving lobster weren't directly mentioned, Zozo’s and Ocean 362 are recommended for fine dining and could potentially offer seafood dishes including lobster. These restaurants are well-regarded for their ambiance and views, making them suitable choices for a special dinner.

According to forum posts, Cruz Bay offers a ferry service departing at 8:45 AM, 11:15 AM, and 3:45 PM to Charlotte Amalie. From Charlotte Amalie to Cruz Bay, ferries run at 10 AM, 3 PM, and 5:30 PM. Travelers can book tickets in advance online. Additionally, there’s a ferry from Cruz Bay to Red Hook, which operates regularly.

Some users mentioned that the InterIsland Boat Service provides a limited run from Crown Bay to Cruz Bay, which is a popular option, and travelers are advised to reserve seats ahead. This ferry operation is just a 5-minute taxi ride from the airport, making it conveniently accessible for arriving passengers.

Travelers have called out that the ferry service maintains its standard schedule even on holidays. This includes the usual Monday to Friday and Saturday/Sunday schedules, ensuring no disruption in service during public holidays.

According to forum posts, the most common transportation option from STT to the Crown Bay Ferry terminal is by taxi. Travelers have mentioned that the taxi ride typically takes about 5 to 10 minutes.

Some travelers also highlighted the availability of specific taxi services coordinated with the ferry schedules. For instance, Captain Barton and a taxi operator named Yogi are frequently mentioned for their reliable services in getting passengers to the Crown Bay Ferry on time.

For those concerned about catching ferries on time post-flight, it's suggested to pre-book the taxi ride to ensure timely arrival at the ferry terminal.

Some travelers mentioned popular dining spots in Coral Bay such as Aqua Bistro, Skinny’s, known for burgers, and Miss Lucy’s, which offers jazz brunches and full moon events. Additionally, places like Pizzabar in Paradise, Salty Mongoose, and Rhumblines were highlighted.

According to forum posts, Coral Bay offers several activities, including kayaking at Hansen Bay to reach the Lime Out taco bar. Noteworthy beaches and hiking spots include Salt Pond, Rams Head, and Lameshur Beach. Travelers can also explore various small shops for souvenirs.

Travelers have called out Coral Bay for its quieter, more laid-back atmosphere, with occasional live music that can be enjoyed by following the sounds through the streets, indicating a spontaneous music scene.

Forum posts describe Coral Bay as a place where you create your own fun, with no bustling town center but plenty of spots for groceries, eating, and beach activities, making it a favorite for those seeking a tranquil experience.