I thought I did this review, but apparently did not submit one. I went with my husband and daughter who is going to college in Buffalo. I'll start by saying that we each felt very differently about it - I loved it and my rating would be 5 - the old time diner with the counter and stools, kind of close tables, friendly busy zipping around staff... I enjoyed and soaked in the ambience, but my husband wasn't impressed and didn't think it was anything special - and his rating would be a 3; my daughter didn't like it and I would say her rating would be a 2. First - delicious fresh squeezed OJ and good hot coffee; decent food, good wait staff and a lot of menu selections. My husband got corned beef hash - and actually complained (to me) that there were large pieces of corned beef in it - my response was that their corned beef had way more meat in it than the small pieces seen at most places and you can actually see that this is a quality item - I would say that the portion size is huge and 2-3 people could easily share it. My daughter got chocolate chip pancakes (I think) and I got an omelet. I would definitely go back, but (I guess) it won't be with them!