My husband and I were visiting from out of town. We loved Cotton and Rye! I had the fried chicken and my husband had the trout, we split a wedge salad and a honey crisp bread pudding with caramel sauce. All excellent! The service was some of the best we have had anywhere. Guitar player played softly in the corner which was a nice addition. I would recommend a reservation, it was busy on a Tuesday night until 9.