I visited Eileen's when it was raining buckets, and I was having a lazy day. At 3:00 on a Tuesday afternoon, it was practically empty. I stopped in and had a mini blueberry cheesecake which was $3.50. I wouldn't call this stereotypical NYC cheesecake, but I enjoyed it despite the steep price tag. It was lighter and not as dense as Junior's or the Cheesecake Factory, but it still had a unique flavor. There were around ten flavors of the mini cheesecakes, and they all looked good. You can also order full size cheesecakes from here.
If you are going to go here, check out Eileen's Facebook page. Most week days, they had a deal of spend $5 and get a free mini cheesecake, and it would be fun to split and share with a friend. They take credit cards!