Stayed 1 night at the Rittenhouse in Bayfield before my husband did the Point to LaPoint swim in Lake Superior (shows we must be a bit crazy to even do that), but was a beautiful weekend. We have stayed here in the past and have enjoyed the location, views and the hospitality. The staff is tremendous and always helpful. Place is Victorian so do not think this is the modern hotel you may be used to. They have done wonderful upgrades. We had room 2 - queen bed (prefer king, but oh well). Nice fireplace, although not needed in July. Bathroom small but efficient with sink in the bedroom. Wonderful view of Lake Superior. Bed was decent but pillows were foam and a bit firm. No television - I was happy, but my news junkie husband was a bit put off (guess I forgot to tell him that part!). There was no wifi connection in our room at all - the whole time. Front desk did their best, tried to reboot, etc. but didn't help at all. Not sure if this is unusual but beware if in room 2 you may not have any wifi.
Do have drinks on the porch overlooking the city and the lake. Very relaxing - they will get you a drink or bring your own, either way, was a great way to start the dinner.
Did the 5 course dinner - fantastic! Service is great - Betty was our server, both on the porch and for dinner. She was a joy!!!
Would recommend their dinner.

This was our first stay at a B&B and we really enjoyed our visit here!
My husband turned 50 and chose a kayaking tour of the caves on Lake Superior. I spent hours on the internet reviewing hotel options. I wanted to make sure it was perfect for this special occasion. I didn't know what to expect as we are pretty picky about food and cleanliness is a priority for me.

As soon as we walked into the Inn we were impressed! It was lovely and everything from the decor, food, service, and cleanliness was met with our high expectations! I could go on and on and describe our experience but for me photos speak the most in volumes so I will include those to help you make your decision.

One thing I would advise is make sure you make your dinner and complimentary breakfasts reservation when booking. They are always full!

We enjoyed our stay so much that we have been telling friends and family to return with us at another date!

Thank you Old Rittenhouse!

I've stayed at the Old Rittenhouse three times and the place is the grand dame of inns in Bayfield. The property is beautifully maintained and I can't imagine how much work it was to update this place with modern plumbing and other mechanicals.

Even the little things are perfect. The air conditioner is our room was silent. We never heard it kick in. The king size bed has just the right amount of firmness.

Never used the whirlpool hot tub, but it's there.

The is staff is friendly, yet you never get the sense they're hovering around.

We didn't eat dinner here. The menu looked fabulous, but it just wasn't the vibe we were looking for and Bayfield has plenty of options. Their dinner menu is pricey, less than the soon-to-close acclaimed Wild Rice, but more than the casual spots a few block away where you can eat outside with a fantastic view of the harbor.

Breakfast was excellent.

The only suggestion I have for the owners is regarding happy hour on their great wrap around porch. Rather than hits us for $7 for a sangria during happy hour, offer a complimentary drink upon arrival. It sets a better tone.