This was our first visit to Bayfield. We spent 4 nights here and had dinner 2 times at the Inn. We spent a good amount of money here. The food was excellent and the room was very nice. For the most part the staff was friendly. At one point felt like we were judged because of my husbands tattoo and the fact that we didn't order wine. I am allergic to an ingredient found in wine, so unfortunately I can't have any. If we where, I'd say don't judge- we are two professional people that have a great appreciation for fine food and supporting Wisconsin businesses. We chose Bayfield over Europe. Despite that we had a great time and enjoyed ourselves.

Our night at Rittenhouse was actual in the second property as there were no rooms available at the Rittenhouse.. We were first of all very impressed when the young lady serving us said she would drive over and meet us there. My wife was almost giddy with excitement as we wandered through the mansion. It was sort of a rainy, cool night, but we had a great time siting on the porch watching the Madeline Island ferry go back and forth between Bayfield and LaPointe. Attention to detail was incredible, and there is nothing I could say that would be negative about the entire experience. The breakfast the following morning was, once again, incredible. (This was our third stay) The entire Rittenhouse experience is such that after all of our years of staying in Ashland on our vacations, we will stay at least one night in one of the properties, even though it is an additional 21 miles to get to Bayfield. The entire staff can be proud of their efforts. About the cost ... yes, the price is more that some of you have paid, BUT the value is awesome. The free breakfast along with the service and the incredible rooms makes this entire experience worth EVERY penny you spend. Husbands:: You should be ashamed if you know about this place and you never take your wife here.

My husband and I stayed here when we decided to take a detour on our way back from Minneapolis to Michigan. It was before the summer season took off, so there was not much happening in town and barely anything open. Luckily we were able to stay here in a great suite with a fireplace, whirlpool tub, and delicious breakfast served downstairs.
There was no TV which was kind of odd, but it helped add to the the historic feel. They do have internet, so we just watched Netflix on the iPad.
All the furniture and decor is very antique and ornate. If you have a respect for that sort of thing, you would love it here. We hope to come back when it is warm enough to use the wrap around porch in front!