We have been renting at OIB for 15 years. Overall, this house was as represented in the pictures and description and was in the location we desired. It was mostly very clean except for a large glob of mold on the baseboard in the dining area. That didn't scare us though!
Two essentials for us were a dock, which was brand new and better than expected, and an outdoor shower, which was useless. The outdoor shower area was locked when we arrived, but the realty company sent out someone to unlock it the next morning. They were very responsive. However, it was literally useless. Many beach houses don't have much water pressure but on full bore the shower was barely a trickle. It would have taken an hour to shower!
To compound the issue, this was the first beach house we have ever rented that did not have an outside hose anywhere. Except for rinsing our feet from a spigot, there was no way to wash off our beach chairs, surf boards, etc...and in a house that promotes the boat dock - it left no way to rinse off the boat or fishing equipment. When we called about it, the realty company told us this is something they don't provide - but this was a first for me and very inconvenient. I would have appreciated a heads up on the website and we could have brought our own.
If they fix the shower and they buy a hose, I would feel good about recommending this house; otherwise, I will look elsewhere next year.