My husband and friends of ours came to Beardslee castle last Saturday night. We had 6:30 reservations for the four of us in the Dungeon. I have seen some reviews here stating that you shouldn't eat in the dungeon area because it is too noisy, but I disagree. It was great. We got to the castle early so that we can sit at the dungeon bar and try 1 or 2 of the over 120 beers that they have available. (They also have drink specials and a full bar). The bartender was very nice and offered to give us some free samples of several beers that were on tap. This was great and we did order a few rounds of some of the beers that she recommended. While we were waiting for our reservation, we played pool and walked around the dungeon area. It was all heavy stone work - a very cool ambiance for sure. Our table was ready early and we had a fantastic site in a semi-circle booth that looked like it was located in a small turret. We ordered appetizers (wings which were spicy but super meaty and cooked perfectly). You can order from the main dining room menu or the dungeon pub menu. If I recall correctly, we all ordered from the pub menu and had hamburgers or chicken sandwiches which were perfectly fine with no complaints. We had a great time here and would like to come back for one of their murder mystery dinners.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.