The cheese pizza for eating in outstanding. The day we ate in the soda machine did not have a full assortment of flavors.
6 - 10 of 26 reviews
The good news is that the large pizzas are large and they are cut "party" style so there are lots of smaller pieces to go around for a crowd. The bad news is that the large pizzas are a bit pricey for not the best quality pizza.
This is my favorite place for lunch in Indy. They have really good sandwiches and salads.
Prices are very reasonable.
You order from the counter, set down and they bring you the food.
I had the 8" Bellacinos Pride pizza. It was relatively small but still almost too much to handle for a lunch. There were a lot of great toppings, and the crust was nice and toasty on the bottom. My colleagues orders grinders and a salad, and they all looked good. The prices were reasonable, and they also had one of the Coke machines that offers over 100 combinations, if you are into that sort of thing. The atmosphere was nothing to get excited about, and it is in a little strip mall / commercial complex. The people were very nice, and I was pleased with the experience.
Recent pizzas we picked up for carry-out were nondescript. The crust seemed similar to packaged grocery-store brands, what little sauce was there lacked taste, and toppings were skimpy. We used to be fans of Bellacino's but unfortunately their pizza can no longer compete with so many better-quality, local alternatives. Grinders or salads may be a better choice.