We visited Sanibel late afternoon, off-season. Drove around wanting to find a casual gulf side seafood restaurant. Couldn't find what we wanted. Mucky Duck - too casual, Mad Hatter and 'Tween Waters - too upscale for what we wanted that night. Getting hungry and cranky we d ecided to leave Sanibel but Traders caught my eye and I remembered the TA reviews. While there's no water view, we were so glad we stopped! Our server - Bubba - was wonderful and the food was delicious! Large portions, prepared well.