My expectations were high walking into this place on a rainy blustery Saturday night. Parking is impossible in Rehoboth, so , for me to go there in a weekend I want it to be worth my time. I called to see if I could wear sneakers, as the 45 degree weather ruined my fashion statement of wearing tall stilettoes and a short shirt. We did manage to be seated quickly. The bathroom wasn't clean. An employee emerged from the unisex bathroom leaving paper towels, toilet paper, and a wet mirror. I don't think he made the mess, but he didn't have enough pride in his place of employment to clean up. I went with 3 other guests. My friend order the yellow-eyed fish, but-called it "yellow-tail". The waitress seemed annoyed that she mispronounced this fishes' name. We laughed, but she didn't. The waitress took our other 3 orders, then said, "what sides do you want with your yellow-eyed fish? My friend answered her question. We first received the tuna tartar. It was a generous helping for $20 of tuna with only a few wontons. A wonderful mix of sea weed and a gently floated raw quail egg. The oysters came with wonderful mixers and beautiful presentation. This is were it all fell apart. The lobster mac and cheese was $34. It was too big. It was big enough for 3 portions. It was ridiculous size. Also, it could have used pepper or salt or something other than relying on the cheese for flavors. The sword fish was very moist. That was acceptable. My friend who ordered the yellow-eyed fish only received her side dishes, not entrée. The waitress defended herself saying that she never ordered the entrée-- even after the snooty remark about the yellow-tail fish (not yellow-eyed). Finally, the waitress ordered the fish for after arguing. Who orders 2 sides for dinner? Okay, my Bolognese was so boring. It had nice presentation, but no rice or pasta or orzo, just a stew of fish with tomato sauce. The cocktail was average. This is rated number one? Why? There was supplies in the hall way. The lights were so dim I couldn't read the menu. There was paper on top of the white table clothes. There was a $99 entrée in a place wear you can wear tennis shoes. So disappointed.