We spent three nights at the Ameenjeerah last week and it was a really brilliant stay. The bar staff really looked after us and the food, (although the menu was limited) was really tasty! Breakfast was good too.
The rooms were well maintained and the views were just to die for. The two pools are fantastic and easily the best place to watch the sunset from on Koh Tao.
The hotel is undergoing a little bit of renovation and the sky pool and some of the areas around the hotel are a little run down and that's why i couldn't quite bring myself to give a five star review. But, i'm sure when things are all finished it will be fantastic.
It's a 15 minute walk into Sairee Village but is very steep especially in the heat on the way back - however, this is necessary in order to get the great views!
We would come back for the views and staff alone.More