We stayed for 3 nights in February and thoroughly enjoyed our stay. The hosts are very welcoming and friendly, and provide you with lots of good information about the surrounding area
We had to switch rooms, and found both very comfortable.
Breakfast, at the dining room table with the other guests (with Neil making the fresh coffee) is excellent. Neil & Susan are well travelled and have lots of stories to share.
Location, on the Otago peninsula, is very good. Ten minutes drive fom Dunedin and within 10 - 20 minutes of the places to visit on the peninsula.
There is no restaurant in Macandrew Bay in the evening, but the pub at Portobello along the road serves very good bar meals, and is a lively place which seems to be well used by the locals.