Sorry, this review is really late, so I'll be a little light on the details. My wife and I were just discussing how much we enjoyed this place when we were here last October, and I realized I never wrote a review.
The owner stopped by our table and offered us appetizers - very friendly and extremely passionate about his restaurant. We loved it. I can't remember exactly what I had (it was really good), but my wife ordered the paella and it was amazing (apparently why I forgot what I had).
We sat outside the restaurant and it was very pleasant. We were far enough away from the hustle and bustle of the main street that it was fairly quiet. If we were ever in the area again, we would not hesitate to stop in for another meal (rather than try someplace new).
We thought it was a very good value. I can't really compare the value to other restaurants in the area, but if I were to compare it to similar experiences in Milwaukee, it was a great deal. Hope this helps.