We came across Banana Bay because it is right down the road from Garden of the Groves. The restaurant is right on Fortune Beach, a gorgeous attraction itself. Staff was friendly and prices average for the island. They rent chairs for $4.50/day (a steal compared to what resorts charge). He had the conch burger -- taste was ok, but it was similar to a conch fritter (some small pieces of conch spread throughout, but more breading than conch). I had the mahi mahi which was GREAT. The best meal I had on our entire trip.
From other reviews it sounds like this place gets packed in peak months, but if you have the chance to go off-season, DO IT! It felt like our own paradise.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.