Buen Appetito has two locations. Once close to the docks and one up up the hill. We went to the one up the hill from the docks.
We both ordered a pizza and they were fantastic. Very, very thin crust. Great sauce!
As I understand it from our host, the one closer to the dock serves pizza with a bit of a thicker crust and had we had one more night on the island, we would of tried it!
I have to say, we never had a bad meal on Ometepe!