We stayed at Arya Apartments from 6th -20th September and they were fantastic, made to feel really welcome from Arihan,Pinar, Geroge and Ozzie. We would definitely stay here again.
As for meals we ate at Alins Grill(who were amazing, it was my partners birthday and I emailed in advance, they decorated the table and had roses etc), Meryem Yemek Evi, Tin Tins, Taj Mahal, Tommys, Wayside, Majestic, Hanedans, Cafe Annes.
The best meals I had were Tommy's and Hanedans.
We did a Jeep Safari which was brilliant, the walk to Marmaris is also good.
On the negative side the locals seemed to be a wee bit more forward, some silly comments from them.