Considering a trip 10/14-10/19. I have visited multiple times, teen daughter has been there once, husband and son are 1st timers.
I take the small room and no view reviews with a grain of salt as that is exactly what I expect. Will mostly use room for sleeping only - budget and proximity to Central Park priority.
Husband, myself, and 2 full sized teenagers.
La Quinta CP - noticed it on my last trip - would get 2 queen rooms
6 Columbus - could do 1 room
Hotel Belleclaire -could do 1 room
Mpst recently have stayed at Affinia 50 and Hampton Inn Chelsea.
We will likely do a split stay of UWS and then somewhere in the Greenwich Village area. Better nights to stay in 1 of these areas over another?