What really is the best way to get from NYC to Plattsburg? Seems like no direct flights from any airports in NYC to Plattsburg. Would I really have to do a 5-6 hour drive from NYC or an Amtrak for 7 hours? Thanks!
Bus will be cheapest and also the longest. But a lot depends on where you are coming from.
Without knowing where you are coming from it's difficult to give a sensible answer.