Does anyone have a good recommendation for a day tour that visits both Kicker Rock and Cerro Brujo?
wondering if you are referring to the 360 tour? We did Kicker Rock only since we didn't want to be rushed and on a boat all day and it was excellent. Saw schools of fish, swam w sea lions, and spotted turtles and sharks. Not sure what time of year you will be traveling, but we found it easy to book the tours when you are on the island for much better prices than booking online in advance.
We did a dive/snorkel trip with Wreck Bay Divers & it was excellent! My husband & I dove while our kids snorkeled.