We are planning a 4 day trip to NYC Nov. 29-Dec.3rd. (I'm assuming that all Xmas Markets, window decorations, tours & shows have started by then.) We would like to stay on the Upper West Side and have narrowed the hotel search between these 2 hotels. Looks like the subway is convenient for both. NYLO has a higher rating on TA, but the fees and taxes are more than Hotel Newton. However, it is newer and the room looks larger. (no fridge or microwave though)
Just wondering if anyone has been to both and can give me pros and cons to help make a decision.
Thanks for any advice!