My husband and I are planning a trip to Quebec City over New Year's Eve weekend (4 nights) and we are having a hard time deciding between these two seemingly great properties. I am leaning towards the Frontenac because I think it would may be a little more festive and decorated for the holidays (I am a sucker for Christmas decorations). My husband likes the room at the Auberge Saint-Antoine much more than the room we would be staying in at the Frontenac. We are also thinking maybe we spend 2 nights in each place, and experience both. Any suggestions would be appreciated.