We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Trip Report - Intro and travel

New York
Level Contributor
64 posts
Trip Report - Intro and travel

Typically, I do not write a trip report as I figure nobody really cares about my vacation, but I know that this year folks (myself included) are hanging on every word, anxious to hear updates on the little island that could. As such, I will take my shot at a trip report with one big disclaimer – I am not as funny nor entertaining as 54b. You see, as much as I have tried to fight it all my life, I am not just an engineer by trade, but by birth as well and that genetic curse comes with a lack of writing skills. Besides me, a fifty-something college professor, this trip included my husband who we will call Phil. His name is not really Phil, but if you are a fan of the show “Modern Family”, you get the picture. He is an amazing guy but can be oh so geeky (surprise! He is also an engineer). Next, there was our 22 year old son who we will call Nature Boy (NB). That’s not his real name either, but all his life he has been one with nature and a critter whisperer. This trip was a celebration of his graduation from the University of Pittsburgh this spring (can you guess his major?). Finally, our 20 year old daughter, Sorority Girl (SG), was along for the ride. She has nothing in common with the rest of us and looks nothing like us, but we have learned to make it work.

It has been five years since we have taken a family vacation and five years since we have been to St. John. My husband and I have visited Virgin Gorda several times over those five years but we felt St. John needed us more this year. Although we live in Rochester, NY, we booked the trip in and out of Pittsburgh, PA. It was a combination of price, having the jfk-roc leg of our flight cancelled on 2 out of the last 3 trips and the fact that NB is still living in Pittsburgh that convinced me to go that route. On 5/27 SG, Phil and I headed to Pittsburgh, picked up NB, had dinner at a surprisingly good Mexican restaurant in a college neighborhood and headed to the airport Marriot where we had a very good deal for a park and fly. So I have already mentioned that on 2 of my last trips home from STT I have had a leg cancelled, but that is just the tip of the iceberg; I am the world’s most unlucky flier. It is so bad that coworkers specifically request NOT to be booked on the same flights with me. Over the last decade, I have had a flight cancelled on average once in every three trips. You name a reason, and I have experienced it. As a result, I got zero sleep as I compulsively checked the PIT and the Delta websites all night long. My worry was for naught as our flights went off without a hitch and we even arrived at STT almost 30 minutes early. I don’t even think there was any turbulence, but my memory of the jfk-stt leg is a little fuzzy as we had brought quite a supply of mini bottles on the plane with us. In case you were wondering, somewhere in the Delta magazine it states that you are only allowed to consume alcohol on the airplane if it is sold to you by a Delta employee on the plane, but I didn’t see it until I was in a state of not really caring. Finally…our vacation had started.

I had pre-arranged a private taxi to take us from the airport to Red Hook but he was not waiting for us. After several attempts to contact him, we just got in another taxi and paid $90 for a private ride to the ferry. By now NB was starving and we had 45 minutes to spare so he and Phil went to Fish Tails and grabbed some burgers and fries. We ate those on the ferry, sitting in the sunshine, with the wind blowing through our hair and life was good. All four of us were giddy with anticipation and could not contain our excitement as Cruz Bay came into view. Courtesy Jeep Rental met us at the ferry and drove us to their office (which is being reconstructed) so we could pick up our four door Jeep. Our villa greeter met us at Courtesy and led us to a home away from home, Palm Hill Villa. Phil and I love Gallows Point Resort and have always stayed there in the past, but unfortunately, we were not able to convince NB and SG that sleeping on a pullout couch and a rollaway in the living room would be fun. In case you didn’t infer it from her nickname, SG is kind of high maintenance. It is a bit contradictory because she has spent the last four summers working at a summer camp where she sleeps in a cabin with about 14 girls for nine weeks, but she does like luxury when she is on vacation. We were actually a little worried that she might suffer some sort of Starbucks withdrawal on vacation, but being able to drink legally more than made up for it.

We arrived at the villa (I will write a separate review of it later), picked our rooms, dropped our suitcases and headed back out for supplies. Armed with our Wegman’s bags brought from home (when you are from Rochester, any bag is a Wegman’s bag) we hit up both St. John’s Market and Starfish. Three-hundred dollars later we headed back to the villa for pool and rum time. The four of us hung out in the pool, enjoying the sunset and each other’s company. Later, Phil and I cooked dinner and it was lights out early as we were all exhausted.

8 replies to this topic
Dallas, TX
Level Contributor
892 posts
8 reviews
1. Re: Trip Report - Intro and travel

No disclaimer needed...if given the choice, always trust the engineer's report :)

Looking forward to reading your reactions to the state of the island. Thanks for contributing.

Fairhope, Alabama
Level Contributor
506 posts
113 reviews
2. Re: Trip Report - Intro and travel

You're doing a great job so far! I look forward to reading more. Enjoy!

Tomball, Texas
Level Contributor
4,384 posts
41 reviews
3. Re: Trip Report - Intro and travel

All of these trip reports make my heart happy!

And please do not rebook and be on any of my flights. I've had enough issues with them this week.

Level Contributor
484 posts
13 reviews
4. Re: Trip Report - Intro and travel

Thank you Jean!! Can't wait to read more.

Level Contributor
6,105 posts
133 reviews
5. Re: Trip Report - Intro and travel

So true octoberluver!

Can’t wait to read the rest...I do anesthesia so can relate to the engineer in you, but you seem way less boring than me!!

Hillsborough, North...
Level Contributor
39 posts
6. Re: Trip Report - Intro and travel

This is great! As a native Rochesterian, alumni of SUNY at Buffalo and now North Carolinian for the past 25 years, I only use my Wegmans bags too. And we don't even have a Wegmans here (YET!). We'll be bringing ours to St. John next month so we don't leave any extra trash behind.

My husband (much like Phil himself) does a lot of cooking and we plan to eat many of our dinners at the villa. So we appreciated your shopping suggestions.

I loved your entire trip report......it was informative and entertaining!

Smithfield, Rhode...
Level Contributor
2,299 posts
37 reviews
7. Re: Trip Report - Intro and travel

So far love the report. My brother has the worst luck when he flies as well. Either huge delays or cancellations.

Him and my son both live in Texas. Everyone comes “home” for Christmas and my son gets here no issue. Not my brother! Lol!

My son is an engineer!!!

Have fun!

Level Contributor
529 posts
97 reviews
8. Re: Trip Report - Intro and travel

I never thought that I would be reading about Wegmans on this forum. As a young kid I lived near what I believe was the first big Wegmans that was built on Ridge Road in Greece, a Rochester suburb for those of you who are surprised Athens has a Wegmans. Wegmans has now spread to Massachusetts and some people love it so much they are called Wegmaniacs. I would be happier shopping at Starfish or St. John Market. Thanks for the trip reports.

Reply to: Trip Report - Intro and travel
Get notified by e-mail when a reply is posted