The serving portion is truly enormous but it's very delicious. We had the seafood platter for 2 pax and we can't barely finished half of it. Quite a queue during peak hours but it's definitely worth the wait.
1 - 10 of 5,082 reviews
Is it the best restaurant I have ever eaten at... No but it was very good! It is a hive of activity, they must serve 1000 people a night and they do it well. You arrive (after you make your reservation) and go to the...More
True. Very very big portions and good food. Nice (NYC) traditional decoration and good ambience (more like Frank Sinatra background music). The service however was nothing spectacular, e.g. when booking we mentioned we were dining there as part of our honeymoon but we were seated...More
Went to Phantom of the Opera and had booked reservations here for after the matinee show. It was so close to the theatre. Food was Italian family style. Portions were generous and the prices couldn't be beat for feeding a family of 5. We had...More
The setting! Exciting. Busy. The food! Flavorful. Perfect. The service! Friendly. Timely. Helpful. Call ahead for reservations. We walked in and ate at the bar as the table wait was 90mins. The bartender was great! Very experienced and had worked at Carmine's over 15 yrs....More
Very helpful waitress. Tons of good food! Our family of five enjoyed it all! Because it's family style, we had to agree on two dishes. It worked fine for us. Made a reservation several days in advance.
What isn't to like about Carmine's? We have been to NY numerous times and we always make a stop here. The Italian Cheesecake is to DIE for!!!
Have friends from outer town and wants some good pasta. Normally we'll stay out of the mid-town area because of price and crowded restaurants. But they have never been to Time Square, we figure we can kill two birds with one stone. Arrived around 6:00...More
We had a lovely meal at Carmine's. I chose it off tripAdvisor as something close to my hotel and for some good American-Italian. The one thing I didn't realise though is the size of the portions. They are ma-husive! There were just two of us...More