The food was authentic New York style. The atmosphere was typical New Yorker style. Place could be a little clearer
1 - 10 of 72 reviews
Been eating here as a pre game ritual before NY Rangers games since the fall of 1975. Always great. The vibe hasn't changed one bit and I love it. I have eaten gyros in a dozen countries including Greece and this place is still the...More
My husband and I went here for Lunch! I got gyro platter and my husband got gyro sandwich. The meat was dried out the tzatziki sauce tasted like they spilled sugar in it. We ended up throwing most of it away. Totally ruined my GYRO...More
My wife and I have been going to Gyro II for the last 36 years. It never disappoints. Sure the place is a little shop worn but that's part of the charm. The staff is friendly and quick. The gyros (chicken or lamb) are wonderful...More
The gyro are large and filled with plenty of filling. The establishment itself has lost a star because of poor restroom stall and the window view that over looked the Avenue has been covered with an electronic board. The window faces Madison Square Gardens.
I've been going to the place since the 1970s. Conveniently located across the street from Madison Square Garden it was the usual meeting place before going to a Knick or Ranger game or a concert. 40 years later, I always make it a point to...More
I first discovered Gyro II after a Jethro Tull concert at Madison Square Garden in 1973. I was immediately taken by the tender lamb strips and the unique tasting sauce. Although I left New York for Arizona many years ago, I never miss a chance...More