Having dined at Atlantic Fish several years ago, I was disappointed with our dinner experience this time. First the positives: Good bread, good salad, good wine. Also, our server was friendly, attentive and kind. Now the negatives: The seafood. For an iconic Boston seafood establishment,...this constitutes a total fail. The skate was small, dry, tough and had an ammonia taste. Clearly, it was not fresh. The halibut was small, tough, dry and overcooked. I just don’t understand how such a famous seafood restaurant can do such a poor job.More

Four of us went here for dinner and all meals were good. The Shrimp Cocktail and Scallop appetizers were particularly tasty. The Sangria was better than all but one place I had it in Florida, which says some thing for a Massachusetts bar. The service...was equal to the food. I recommend this place for seafood.More

Excellent oysters, great vibe. Book in advance or take your chances finding a space at the bar. Lively atmosphere and really good seafood. Well worth a visit

We don't get down to Boston very often and remembered dining at Atlantic Fish Co. The food and service didn't disappoint. Atlantic Fish Co. is just a block from The Lennox Hotel. Do make a reservation as the restaurant was full even at 6 pm.

An enjoyable experience here. Food was good (nothing more than that though) and service excellent. Bar service excellent too. It’s a busy place with a good vibe

I enjoyed my meal but despite very good, fresh ingredients the cooking was not as special as I'd expected given the reviews I'd read beforehand. The ambience was very good for a Saturday lunch time and the service was very attentive

My wife and I dined at Atlantic Fish yesterday during a visit for an event in Boston. We had reservations for 4:00 PM, but our event ended early. We called the restaurant at 2:20 to see if we could change our reservation to 2:30, and...they were extremely accommodating. When we arrived, we were seated immediately in a comfortable corner booth, even though the restaurant was absolutely packed. My wife and I each had the Super-Lump Crab Cake as appetizers, followed by Lobster Bisque. The Lobster Niçoise served as my wife's entrée, and I had the Whole Mediterranean Branzino. My wife ordered wine by the glass, and I enjoyed two excellent cocktails, The Old Hudson. Our food was delicious, and our server was extremely attentive and friendly. Our overall experience was outstanding. When I read negative reviews, I can only imagine people who are either foreign to the concept of fine dining or, more likely, people who are simply riding on far too high a horse.More