Yummy! We noshed peanut butter cookies as we walked the Castro. We'll be back for more. Next time chocolate chip?
1 - 10 of 110 reviews
The cookies at Hot Cookie are actually good, which was a bit of a surprise to me. Usually, places that are hyped up like this are just average, but my husband and I enjoyed our cookies. One of his was burned, which was unfortunate, but...More
Every kind of cookie imaginable--all delicious! We wandered around the district found the Hot Cookie and munched while we walked. The cookies were very expensive and worth every penny! You can't go wrong!
The Hot Cookie is a small but very popular shop in the Castro District. Every kind of cookie you might imagine, made on location, and probably the best tasting you have every eaten. This is in the Castro District, which is an interesting and enjoyable...More
Seriously the best warm cookie I ever ate!! Wish I had gotten milk tho. The cookies have fun names and are sold by weight, but I didn't find them too expensive. Shop is very small, walk in, order and walk out kind of place. Highly...More
I'm a bit addicted to the pokie cookies here (with M&Ms), but they're all good. Kind of like Mrs. Fields used to be, but a bit crispier around the edges. Very decedent. Plus the staff is always super friendly, funny, and attentive. I'm not really...More
This humble cookie palace has whatever you may be craving and more that you want but didn't know you wanted. The lines vary from short and fast to long and gratification-delaying.
BEST COOKIES EVER!! This place honestly makes the best cookies anyone I know has ever tried. Every time I go to San Francisco (from Modesto) I get cookies at the Hot Cookie for everyone in the house. They're just so good. They truly are 100...More
We got cookies for the kids to eat as it was next to the strain station when we visited the Castro. Cookies are hot, there was a long line up )which is part of the hype) and there is no where to sit down inside...More