Way over priced. Generic gross fries, tiny servings and outrageous prices. Not worth the time and money.
1 - 10 of 10 reviews
We only went to the Sugar Shack for ice cream. I asked if they had ice cream - the clerk said, "of course." I didn't see prices but I figured soft ice cream couldn't cost that much so I ordered two twist cones. The total...More
This place is located in the old Sugar Shack location. The Sugar Shack had really good burgers and I guess I just assumed they would still b good under new ownership. Wrong! I ordered a hamburger meal. The patty was absolutely tasteless and very small,...More
I love this place. Good ice cream cones, shakes, malts. old fashioned sodas, etc. They do serve food also although I have never tried it. The ladies working in there are so fun to talk to. Great hometown family atmosphere. If you are looking for...More
The soft serve ice cream is ok, I'll give it that. The service is absymal, and the food unremarkable except in it's lack of flavor or quality. Prices are outrageous, and the place feels unkempt and dirty. Save your money and eat somewhere else.
Would not eat there. Ice cream is ok. The review about the old fashioned ice cream is about a the sugar shack in Greybull Wyoming not this one in Pinedale Wyoming.
I've never eaten a worse hamburger. The fries were old and cold. Didn't even eat them. And $9 for a burger and fries no drink? I would rather eat an egg salad sandwich from the gas station.
Talk about nostalgia; a great place to get a milkshake; not just in the glass; but you get the old fashioned metal milkshake maker cup...It's like getting 2 milkshakes or malts for the price of one....It's like the old fashioned malt shop......You can get sandwiches...More