good (not outstanding) steaks, great wines and good sides. prices are a little too high for area and quality of food.
1 - 10 of 250 reviews
First time for me in Milwaukee, a local colleague told me it would have been worth it, and it really was! Great fillet, extremely tasty and tender, excellent wild salmon, very good dessert. Negative sides being in my opinion the lights, too low (initially you...More
This restaurant has a great decoration but the best of all is the filet The quality of the meat they serve is excellent, it almost melts in your mouth The salads are serve very cold and in a good size too if you ever visit...More
I wish I would have been hungrier when we went here for dinner. I had a steak salad that was very good but my wife and other family members had steaks and they were awesome. Prices very steep. Service was great even at 10:30 at...More
Thank you so much for the review Richard! Our steaks are so amazing because we have our own farm where we get the meat from so it truly is some of the freshest meat you may ever eat! We hope to see you back in!
Our tour guide recommended this place as the best steak in town. She didn't warn us that reservation were required and it's very high-end. However, they were gracious enough to seat us in the bar area which was perfectly fine. The prices were high-end as...More
I've been coming here for years but tonight I brought my mom here for her first time for her birthday. She loved it! From suggesting a wine to a meal my mother would enjoy to bringing a dessert with a candle and everything, Addie went...More
Thank you so much for the review! We are glad to hear that you are a life-time customer, but we are even happier to hear how amazing the birthday dinner went for your mother! We hope to see you back soon!
My husband and I have not ate here since we were first dating in 2010. We were not as sure it would be as good as the first time. Come to find out it was better. I had a flirtini (11$) tasted like a fresh...More
Thank you so much for the review! We have to admit that we also are in love with the food! We look forward to seeing you back soon!
I sponsored a corporate dinner at Carnivore and was very pleased with all aspects of the experience. They don't have private dining, but we were able to reserve a large single table. If you love premium steaks with an excellent wine list, this is the...More
We are so happy to hear that your corporate dinner went well! Our decanters are always a hit with people. We hope to see you in the future again!
I travel a lot on business and always try to visit an independent steak house in the City in am visiting. Don't miss Carnevor if you are in Milwaukee. Outstanding steaks. Great wine list. Would cost 2-3x more if it were in Chicago or NY...More
Thank you so much for the review! We are glad that you pick Carnevor when you are in Milwaukee. Our steaks truely are amazing and we pride ourself on our wine list!
I heard it was closed what a disappointment. I entertained there, and treated myself many times. For anyone who enjoys food this WAS the place to go!
Hi Suzanne, Thank you for reaching out and for the great rating! We are indeed still open, we just moved 3 doors south of our original location. We hope you come back and dine with us again soon!