We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Nicolitalia Pizzeria

Menu

APPETIZAHS
Small(6) $4.49
Large(12) $7.99
Breaded Ravioli
With marinara dipping sauce
Small(5) $5.99
Large(10) $10.99
Chicken Wings
Plain, BBQ, Teriyaki, Hot (Buffalo) with dressing: Plain, ranch, house, or blue cheese
Small(5) $4.99
Large(10) $8.99
Chicken Fingahs
With marinara dipping sauce, BBQ, Ranch, or Blue Cheese
Small(1) $3.99
Large(2) $6.99
Cheese Scarpa
With marinara dipping sauce, or house sauce
Small $3.99
Large $6.99
Mozzarella Sticks
With marinara dipping sauce
(6) $4.99
Breadsticks
Garlic butter with grated cheese served with a side of ranch, marinara, or house dressing
(3) $2.99
Meaballs
with marinara dipping sauce topped with cheese
SOUPS AND SALADS
All salads come with a homemade roll and your choice of salad dressing: Homemade creamy Italian (house specialty), blue cheese, ranch, Italian, light Italian, or raspberry vinaigrette
$1.99
Side Salad (does not include roll)
Creamy Italian (house specialty), Blue cheese, Ranch, Italian, Light Italian, Raspberry vinaigrette
$4.99
Garden Salad
choose: Creamy Italian (house specialty), Blue cheese, Ranch, Italian, Light Italian, Raspberry vinaigrette
$4.49
Caesar Salad
Creamy Italian (house specialty), Blue cheese, Ranch, Italian, Light Italian, Raspberry vinaigrette
$5.15
Greek Salad
Creamy Italian (house specialty), Blue cheese, Ranch, Italian, Light Italian, Raspberry vinaigrette
CALZONES
$6.99
Calzones
rolled with mozzarella cheese and your favorite toppings into pizza dough to make an Italian "sandwich". Served with 4 oz. of homemade marinara sauce. Your Choice: Broccoli, Eggplant Pahmesan, Chicken Pahmesan, Meatball, Grilled Chicken, Peppahs & Onions, Sausage & Peppahs, Spinach Ricotta, Steak & Peppahs & Onions, Veggies (mushrooms, peppahs, Onions, Broccoli, Tomatoes). Add $0.50 for each additional and/or substitution of toppings. See Build-Yah-Own Pizzas section for available toppings
SPECIALTY PIZZAS
All specialty pizzas are served on a regular thin crust. Specialty pizzas Are Not available in half and half selections.
Medium (12) $13.59
Large (14) $15.99
Xlarge (16) $19.99
Chicken Cacciatore
Grilled chicken, mushrooms, peppahs, onions, and mozzarella on our margarita sauce
Medium (12) $12.09
Large (14) $13.99
Xlarge (16) $16.99
Chicken Mushroom Alfredo
Grilled chicken, mushroom, & mozzarella in our creamy alfredo sauce
Medium (12) $12.09
Large (14) $13.99
Xlarge (16) $16.99
Chicken Pahmesan
Breaded chicken breast lathered with extra portion of sauce & mozzarella, topped with romano cheese
Medium (12) $13.09
Large (14) $14.69
Xlarge (16) $17.99
Chicken Pesto
Chicken breast, broccoli, spinach, & gahlic in our creamy alfredo sauce
Medium (12) $14.59
Large (14) $15.99
Xlarge (16) $19.99
Cucina Paradiso
One of our newest creations with spinach, gahlic butter sauce, grilled chicken, pahmesan, mozzarella, and almonds
Medium (12) $11.59
Large (14) $12.99
Xlarge (16) $14.99
Mahgarita
A must for our Italian pizza lover. Our famous Mahgarita is pled with fresh plum tomatoes, fresh gahlic, romano cheese, basil, & seasonings
Medium (12) $13.09
Large (14) $13.99
Xlarge (16) $17.59
Mahk Anthony
Chicken cutlets & spinach pizza sprinkled with gahlic, romano cheese, crushed hot & bacon topped with mozzarella
Medium (12) $13.59
Large (14) $15.69
Xlarge (16) $19.69
Meatza China
Pizza loaded with bacon, hamburger, pepperoni, sausage, & ham for the carnivore in you!
Medium (12) $12.99
Large (14) $14.99
Xlarge (16) $18.59
Nicolitalias Special
The most-frequently-ordered toppings in the Boston area highlights this specialty pizza; sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, & peppahs
Medium (12) $14.59
Large (14) $15.99
Xlarge (16) $19.99
Italian Stallion
Yo Adrian! Come try this pizza! Even if you are not a fan of Rocky Balboa, you'll be definite fan of this spinach, pepperoni, steak, gahlic, mozzarella & romano, sprinkles with our blend of Italian seasonings.
BUILD YOUR OWN PIZZAS
Personal (8") $5.99
Medium (12") $8.99
Lahge (14") $9.99
Xlahge (16") $11.99
Thin crust
Medium (12") $10.99
Lahge (14") $11.99
Xlahge (16") $14.99
Deep Dish
Personal (8") $0.49
Medium (12") $0.99
Lahge (14") $1.29
Xlahge (16") $1.49
Regular Topping (each)
Anchiovies, Bacon, Banana Peppars, Black Olives, Brocoli, Extra cheese, Fried Eggplant, Gahlic, Ham, Hamburguer, Jalapeños, Meatball, Mushroom, Red Onions, Pepperoni, Peppahs, Pineapple, Salami, Sausage, Sliced Tomatoes, Spinach, Almonds
Medium (12") $1.49
Lahge (14") $1.99
Xlahge (16") $2.49
Supah Topping (each)
BB Chicken, Buffalo Chicken, Grilled Chicken, Teriyki Chicken, Ricotta Cheese, Feta Cheese
Medium (12") $1.99
Lahge (14") $2.49
Xlahge (16") $2.99
Elite Toppings (each)
Artichoke Hearts, Roasted Red Peppers
MAKE YOUR OWN PIZZA AT HOME!
Makes a 14 large thin crust pizza, includes dough, cheese and sauce with instructions. Add topping for $1.39 each. Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Onions, Peppers, Sausage, Ham, Pineapple
$1.99
Pizza Dough (14")
$6.99
Pizza Kit
COFFEE DRINKS
Served all day.
Small 12oz $2.09
Regular 16oz $2.49
Black
Small 12oz $1.49
Regular 16oz $1.54
Expresso
Small 12oz $3.19
Regular 16oz $3.69
Cappuccino
Small 12oz $3.19
Regular 16oz $3.69
Latte
Small 12oz $3.19
Regular 16oz $3.69
Mocha
Small 12oz $2.49
Regular 16oz $2.99
Americano
Small 12oz $2.49
Regular 16oz $2.99
Hot Chocolate
DESSERTS
Small $1.59
Large $2.49
Chocolate dipped $2.99
Cannoli
$3.99
Boston Italian Cream Pie
A decadent, triple-layered chocolate cake
KID'S
all kid's meals come with a small soda
$3.99
Chicken Fingers (3 Per Order)
Comes with ranch, honey mustard, or BBQ sauce
$3.99
Kid's Breadsticks (4)
Comes with ranch or marinara sauce
$3.99
Meaballs (4)
Topped with marinara sauce and cheese
DRINKS
Small 16oz $1.69
Large 32oz $2.99
Pepsi Products
About
Informal counter-service shop specializing in Boston-style pizza, plus other casual Italian food such Calzones, Strombolis, and Salads. Catering, carry-out, and dine-in services are available.
PRICE RANGE
US$ 5 - US$ 16
Meals
Lunch, Dinner
CUISINES
Pizza, Italian
FEATURES
Seating, Parking Available, Television, Highchairs Available, Wheelchair Accessible, Accepts American Express, Accepts Mastercard, Accepts Visa, Free Wifi, Accepts Discover, Takeout, Free Off-Street Parking, Accepts Credit Cards
Reviews (67)
Filter reviews
66 results
Traveller rating
38
15
4
4
5
Traveller type
Time of year
LanguageEnglish
38
15
4
4
5
Show reviews that mention
All reviews breadsticks calzone salad pizza place nick crust dressing toppings
FilterEnglish
Updating list...
1 - 10 of 66 reviews
Reviewed 28 June 2018

I don't share all the superlative reviews. There is much to like--huge toppings list, 5 cheese choices, 14 sauces, 3 different crusts--but the pizza I tried did not satisfy my palate. There are so very many pizza places and tastes and I have tried quite...More

Date of visit: June 2018
Thank Gary W
Reviewed 20 March 2018 via mobile

Had the family special. Truly incredible. The house garlic dressing is great as a salad dressing, dip for the delicious breadsticks and a great dip for the pizza-even though the pizza is incredible on its own! Excellent food at a great price!! 10/10 would go...More

Date of visit: March 2018
Thank jaxse2014
Nicolitalia P, Manager at Nicolitalia Pizzeria, responded to this reviewResponded 21 March 2018

Thank you so much for the visit and the review! Look forward to seeing you again.

Reviewed 11 January 2018

Our party of nine (teenagers to adults) all agreed this was great food. The service was so friendly and excellent. Everything was fresh, which made a bit longer cook time, but it was worth it! Excellent salad, amazing house dressing, wonderful breadsticks, calzone, & pizza....More

Date of visit: January 2018
Thank MarthaU89
Reviewed 9 October 2017

Don't let the negative reviews turn you off from Nico's. The restaurant is under new management with owners that are very involved in the daily operations. They are working with Nick to bring back the flavor and style of pizza that made this place great...More

Date of visit: October 2017
1  Thank Steve B
Reviewed 26 April 2017 via mobile

Very good thin crust pizza. Good ingredients and sauce. They have numerous choices and several ingredient options. The margaretta pie was tasty as was my meat and vegetable pie. The staff is friendly and the pies are delivered fairly quickly. A good spot for those...More

Date of visit: April 2017
Thank Brookspal
Reviewed 4 March 2017

They call it "Boston-style" pizza. I call it delicious. MSN votes the Queen Margotte the best in Utah, but I prefer the Nicolitalia's Special or the Strada di Roma. The green salad was great with their house dressing, but the croutons, which I don't usually...More

Date of visit: February 2017
1  Thank Namealreadyinuse
Reviewed 18 January 2017

This is the place for pizza. The staff is friendly and focused on your needs. Don't forget to order a salad so you can taste the homemade dressing!More

Date of visit: November 2016
Thank Dave C
Nicolitalia P, Owner at Nicolitalia Pizzeria, responded to this reviewResponded 23 January 2017

Dave. We are glad you like our food and service. Yes, our homemade dressing keeps being our client's favorite. Even though we are at a different location, we are the same team, same owners, and the same flavor. We look forward to see you again!...More

Reviewed 27 October 2016

Since buying the place from the original owner Nick, this place has continually gone down hill. With their new location they have gotten worse. The product is inferior and very greasy. We have tried it twice in the last month hoping to give them the...More

Date of visit: October 2016
Thank Bob C
Nicolitalia P, Owner at Nicolitalia Pizzeria, responded to this reviewResponded 23 January 2017

Bob. Nick left on May 2012, almost 4 years ago. The products are not just the same but, we checked with Nick about all the products we buy, so we could keep the same quality and flavor. So no, we are not going cheap. At...More

Reviewed 25 July 2016

I have visited Nicoliatlia's Pizzeria several times and each time the food was great. I grew up on the east coast and this was a great taste of home.

Date of visit: November 2015
Thank Craig K
Reviewed 28 June 2016 via mobile

This was a great find in Provo Utah! If you like New York style pizza and don't love the big chain store pizza, this is for you. Delicious crust with unique sauces and combinations. We used a groupon for an even better deal.

Date of visit: June 2016
Thank bromcd
View more reviews
Questions & Answers
Get quick answers from Nicolitalia Pizzeria staff and past visitors.
Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page.
Submit
Posting guidelines
Is This Your TripAdvisor Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more. Claim Your Listing