Got a table outside and had a delicious dinner of coconut shrimp. Service was friendly and the atmosphere inside the building was cool and rustic. Would highly recommend
1 - 10 of 352 reviews
Heard great reviews about the Bay Leaf so I decided I would try it while I was in town by myself. Got there about lunchtime so they were getting kind of busy. Had their Wisconsin burger which was absolutely delicious. Way more than I could...More
My husband and I stop at the Bay Leaf Cafe often when we travel from Rapid City, SD back to Gillette, WY after medical appointments. On November 10th we were looking forward to our visit to the cafe like always. Really chilly outside so I...More
This is not the type of place I would normally eat. However; the service was outstanding and the food was adequate. The Gyro was no better than at a mall food court, but I did enjoy the tabbouleh. My companions loved everything they ordered and...More
Thanks for the review. Perhaps next time you might want to try the Spinach Pie that comes with a side of the tabbouleh... and our Moussaka is another very popular Mediterranean item.
This joyful place offers a fantastic range of choices with great service. A place that cateres to taste and texture, they have quiche that is amazing. Grab a table outdoors in the summer and soak up the sun, or cozy up inside.More
Thank you so much for your review. This is my favorite time of year because we are slower and I can visit more with our customers... I do, however, miss having the outdoor tables cuz we love to have folks bring their dogs by for...More
You must have the Walleye.... Grilled or breaded.... either way is fantastic. This is a great little place to eat. You will find very different items on the menu than your run of the mill restaurants and everything is fresh and yummy! Try it, you...More
Seldom do I rave about a meal. The lamb chops were the absolute best I have ever eaten when we dined at the Bay Leaf Cafe. Three large chops were served. They were seasoned to perfection. The Bay Leaf Cafe is located in what was...More
I eat a vegan diet and had looked forward to this place based upon reviews. While the food was ok it wasn't outstanding as we were expecting. We both had blackbean burgers and found them a bit dry. My friend had the iced tea and...More
We ate here on a cold rainy day, The food was excellent , however the waitress was rude and acted like we were in the way . Soups were good. Desserts were ok. Sandwiches were average. Nothing to write home about.
Really enjoyed this little restaurant - we each had a delicious pasta and fresh salad with house-made dressings. Such a nice change from the typical mid-western restaurant menu. And the lovely hand-made quilts all around the room made for a beautiful and comfortable space.