We went there on Saturday Dec 23 at 7pm. When we first got there it was very busy, we had a reservation for 7 and we only had to wait 5 min. Food was ok, nothing special, but nothing to write home about. The real...More
1 - 10 of 497 reviews
Eight of us walked in with no reservations. We waited but were seated together. Great food and service. A little pricey but worth it for a celebratory meal with friends. Feels like a "rathskeller". Cozy with small bar
The service was very friendly and efficient. I do not really care for the space. It is in the basement and the room just does not flow well.The wine list is adequate. They have a nice menu of small plates. The tuna tartare was very...More
We have fond memories of this restaurant from years ago. It was everything we remembered. We enjoyed a wonderful waiter, had a great meal, and a nice drink. I had the tuna which was fabulous.
This restaurant is attached to the Howard Johnson hotel in Hershey. You might not think about stopping here with so many great restaurants in the Hershey area. You would be missing out on really good food! I had the blackened NY Strip and it was...More
We arrived on a late saturday night for dessert. We had the profiterole (delicious), cheesecake, creme brulee, and the Paris Brest. All outstanding. The young lady that served us couldn't be nicer. Great atmosphere. Next time we will dine there.
It's been over 2 years since I visited What If of Hershey but recently had the opportunity to return as part of a private function. Wow, what an improvement! Their food was absolutely outstanding. The appetizers were delicious (crab dip in particular). Entrees were nicely...More
For travelers and tourists, please be aware that this place is a bit unusual and very much a hit or miss dining experience. Yes, it is in the basement of a Howard Johnson hotel just east of Hershey town center. The location is convenient if...More
Really hesitated going in here when we pulled up. Located in the basement of Howard Johnson motel, we were afraid to go inside. But the place was really busy and we thought we would try it. The food was pretty good. The poor servers were...More