Went there for my birthday on Saturday. We had reservations. It wasn't busy. A woman named Cheryl waited on us. We were treated like we were a nuisance, while Cheryl shmoozed with guests at the other 2 tables, she ignored us. We sat for a...More

I've been eating at the What If Café for 20 (25?) years and have never gone away disappointed. Great food, great atmosphere, and great service. The nice, nice people here make you feel welcome and appreciated. The BYOB makes this quality dining very affordable. It's...More

My husband and I enjoyed a very nice evening at the What If Cafe for our Valentine's Dinner. The food was very good and the service was friendly and prompt. We've been to dinner there many times and have never been disappointed in the quality...More

We tried several small plates, and really enjoyed them. Their crab cakes mysteriously hold together without noticeable breeding, and are delicious! We've heard that it's nice to just sit at the bar, and will eat there next time.

Our party of four stopped for lunch on May 26, 2016, based on a recommendation by our very savvy Mom - age 96, living at nearby Homeland - who joined us. We were looking for a pleasant family lunch and found it very satisfying. The...More

Enjoyed the fixed price ($25) dinner last night with a small group and couldn't be more pleased with the variety of selections, quality of the food and attentive service. Gourmet food at a reasonable price. Yum

I was there mid-week the end of April. The atmosphere is attractive. My waiter was very efficient and attentive. My meal was very good.

Fabulous dinners from appetizer to creme brûlée!! Highly recommend What If Cafe for lunch and dinner. Love the BYOB restaurants! Friendly staff!

Food was excellent, service exceptional and staff went above and beyond. Dined on tomato soup and sandwiches which were delicious, had dessert which was the best. Very clean, friendly and a great find. Everyone very friendly and even helpful in finding places to stay.

The food at What If is worthy of experiencing. It is in quiet neighborhood and in a nondescript building.