We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Greencastle
Log in Join
More
    Help Centre

    Lizzy's Ice Cream & Sandwich

    18 Reviews
    #2 of 2 Dessert in Greencastle#8 of 33 Places to Eat in Greencastle
    ₹American, Fast food
    2753 Buchanan Trl W, Greencastle, PA 17225-9303
    +1 717-597-2888
    + Add website
    Share
    Save
    All photos (1)
    Full view
    Map updates are paused. Zoom in to see updated info.
    Reset zoom
    Overview
    4.5
    18 reviews
    • Excellent56%
    • Very good33%
    • Average11%
    • Poor0%
    • Terrible0%
    19 Jul 2016
    “It's good! ”
    10 May 2016
    “Milkshake stop ”
    Restaurant Hours
    + Add hours
    CUISINES
    American, Fast food
    PRICE
    ₹
    RATINGS
    Service
    Food
    Value
    Atmosphere
    LOCATION
    2753 Buchanan Trl W, Greencastle, PA 17225-9303
    All Details
    Improve This Listing
    Write a Review
    JPMiles / Payback Arrow
    75
    JPMiles / Payback Arrow
    Reviews (18)
    Traveller rating
    Traveller type
    Time of year
    Language

    1 - 10 of 18 reviews

    Reviewed 20 July 2016 via mobile
    It's good!

    It isn't on my "go-to" list of places to eat, but it is a nice place to pick up subs/sandwiches and ice cream when in the area. Nice variety of soft serve and Hershey's ice cream.

    1  Thank duffstatler121
    Reviewed 10 May 2016 via mobile
    Milkshake stop

    We love to stop here for milkshakes. It is our go to for them. The service is always great. The quality is consistent and great. We have never tried any of the food but have good things about it. Price is pretty good as well.

    Thank hspangler
    Reviewed 12 April 2016
    Great ice cream place

    We've stopped here many times on the way home. Great ice cream, both soft serve and frozen ice cream. All great at a fair price, and great service.

    Thank hdempsey
    Reviewed 6 April 2016
    Good Sandwich's and Ice cream

    Stopped to get a milkshake and was very surprised my how clean it is . Employees seem to be very friendly and very nice to us as we placed our orders. Food very good and not all expensive. Next time you go by Lizzy's stop...More

    Thank Ann328
    Reviewed 26 February 2016
    Southwest Ranch Burger!!!

    Very cute sandwich and ice cream shop. Restaurant has a very warm homey atmosphere. Food is A++!! Had the Southwest Ranch Burger - it was incredible! 1/4 lb. burger topped with french fried onions, buffalo chips and spicy ranch Mmmm!!!

    Thank 2YoungFarmers
    Reviewed 4 June 2015
    Great little place

    I go here a couple times a year and it's always good. Everything on the menu is great, and the ice cream is awesome. Very great selection of flavors. The prices and service is great as well.

    Thank duffstatler121
    Reviewed 17 February 2015
    Greatest place to eat in the whole Green Castle area

    The owners are super nice and the customer service is fantastic, the food is to die for and the cleanliness and overall atmosphere is great, I come as far as Washington, DC. to just visit and enjoy a great meal and if I'm spending a...More

    Thank Tony F
    Reviewed 3 November 2014
    A great down-home restaurant

    Lizzys always has great food and wonderful service. You are greeted with a smile and served quickly.

    Thank dml240
    Reviewed 25 July 2014
    Yummmm

    My husband's Aunt and Uncle live near Lizzy's. They recommended that we stop and enjoy some ice cream. The smell of ice cream and cones was wonderful. We all agreed that the ice cream tasted wonderful and now know why this is one of their...More

    Thank Jill B
    Reviewed 2 July 2014
    Try the Crabby Fries!

    Lizzy's is one of our favorite local spots to grab dinner. They have a huge menu selection which includes many different kinds of French fries, burgers, subs, sandwiches and dinners.. I personally love the egg salad. They have a recent menu addition of Crabby fries,...More

    Thank shorty20
    Nearby
    Nearby HotelsSee all 4 hotels in Greencastle
    Castle Green Motor Inn
    9 reviews
    3.66 km away
    Rodeway Inn
    2 reviews
    4.26 km away
    Super 8 Greencastle
    168 reviews
    4.37 km away
    Comfort Inn
    218 reviews
    5.48 km away
    Nearby Restaurants
    Pure and Simple Cafe
    48 reviews
    3.20 km away
    Mikie's Ice Cream & Green Cow
    49 reviews
    2.56 km away
    El Sombrero
    58 reviews
    2.80 km away
    Home Style Family Restaurant
    24 reviews
    2.61 km away
    Nearby Attractions
    Greencastle Coffee Roasters
    15 reviews
    3.02 km away
    Knob Hall Winery
    31 reviews
    15.06 km away
    Whitetail Mountain Resort
    157 reviews
    16.12 km away
    Martins Mill Bridge Park
    12 reviews
    3.42 km away
    Questions & Answers
    Get quick answers from Lizzy's Ice Cream & Sandwich staff and past visitors.
    Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page.
    Posting guidelines
    Submit
    Improve this listing

    Restaurant Details

    Rating summary
    • Food
      Service
    • Value
      Atmosphere
    Average prices
    US$ 5 - US$ 10
    Cuisine
    American, Fast food
    Meals
    Lunch
    Restaurant features
    Takeout, Seating
    Good for
    Child-friendly
    Location and Contact Information
    • Address: 2753 Buchanan Trl W, Greencastle, PA 17225-9303
    • Location: United States  >  Pennsylvania (PA)  >  Greencastle
    • Phone Number: +1 717-597-2888
    Is This Your TripAdvisor Listing?
    Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more. Claim Your Listing
    ;