We thought we were just stoping in for basic bar bites and found a menu worthy of a fine restaurant. A classy back room with a fresh salad bar. Up front were freindly locals telling of the old days in Philadelphia. We had a great...More
1 - 10 of 29 reviews
We planned a quick trip to Poconos with family and O'Donnells came to the rescue! Shrimp pescafreda, chicken piccata, meatballs and penne with salad and bread! Our family of 15 loved it! Thank you so much for accommodating us for a catering order!!
Nice restaurant and bar with excellent food and service. The menu is not large, but offers good variety.
O'Donnells is consistently the best restaurant! Love the scallops and the salad bar is exceptional! We take all of our out if town guests there for dinner and are NEVER disappointed! Love our waitress Dina too! O'Donnells ROCKS!!
We have been at Eagle Lake for almost 30 years. We were looking for someplace different to eat. What looks like a bar is actually a great restaurant! We were surprised at the quality of the food, it was delicious. The filet mignon was excellent,...More
The food, atmosphere, service and salad bar here are all wonderful. Just a little place along the highway, but well worth the stop. My wife's filet was done to perfection, which seems to be , no pun intended, a rare thing these days. The owner/server...More
From the outside you wouldn't know it is so cute inside and great food and drinks! Great service, very friendly.
This place is a solid 4. Ample parking. Nice atmosphere. Friendly service. The salad bar is great. The food is very good. Maybe just a little pricey.
We visited O'Donnells on a sleepy winter afternoon - there are not many food options near Big Bass Lake. We were so pleasantly surprised. The owner was our waiter!! We ordered two grilled chicken sandwiches and they were delicious. Food was fresh and hot, and...More