We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Best restaurant in town! If you don't get their lobster bisque you will have missed an awesome treat. Tasty, rich, thick and full of recognizable lobster!
Their menu is pretty extensive. We enjoyed the soup and a batter fried walleye sandwich that would fill even...More
Had a fabulous dinner with 5 other friends. We were seated almost immediately, and we had very friendly hostesses, and a wonderful waitress. The food was incredible, and everything came out exactly as ordered. The lobster bisque had big chunks of Maine lobster in it,...More
Let me say we went for a late lunch on a weekday (Tuesday). Put-In-Bay is a touristy place that appeals to boaters and others who travel to the island via one of two ferry systems.
Since it was a late lunch and exstremely hot and...More
I go to PIB once a year with a group of 10-12 fellow employees and we always come here. Service this year was fantastic and the food was excellent. We had several of the appetizers with different favorites for each person. I had the perch...More
It's definitely not the Boardwalk that I remember. The Lobster sandwich was just ok it was dripping water and not too many chuncks of Lobster. The Walleye sandwich was $18. The Lobster Bisque was served in a small cup for $9.50. I know this is...More
My wife had to stop in and try the Lobster Bisque. Well, it turned out that this place met their reputation for serving the best she ever had!
When we get the opportunity to go to Put-in bay again, we will definitely stop back!