Our pizza's were delicious. 2 all the way and 1 pep-cheese filled our group up. We celebrated birthdays and had 12 people to feed.
1 - 10 of 69 reviews
Zamarelli’s is the pizza equivalent of the Emperor’s New Clothes. Deep down everyone objectively knows their product is sub-par, but out of guilt, obligation and social pressure they keep spouting its renown. I realize it has been a long time local establishment but I believe...More
I have eaten here a few times. Thier pizza is good. The subs are average. Their wings are deep fried. Their spaghetti and meatballs were average. I recommend sticking to thier pizza. Also, business is Cash Only
Zamarelli's has been making pizza at the corner of Front St. and Midland for as long as anyone can remember. When folks move away the first place they get is a pizza from Zams! No delivery. No credit cards. No problem! Just good pizza.
Don’t let the “greasy pepperoni” fool you. In this case, it’s not a negative. Zamarelli’s is one of our favorite places to get pizza in Grove City. A couple of things you should know: 1. They don’t take cards - no debit cards, no credit...More
If your looking for old style pizza this is the place to go it's so good and its,always hot and taste amazing give it a shot and find out for urself and enjoy
We wait until the clock hits 4:30 pm when they open to make our order. By far the best pizza in town. I do wish they could have regular salads to accompany their pizza. Their salad is more of a lettuce slaw I guess served...More
This pie is pretty good. But not great. It's also cash only and no delivery. The closer you live or eat the pizza the better. It's greasy so it would be nice to be able to eat there when it's fresh out of the oven.
I was born and raised in Grove City and Zamarelli's pizza was a Friday night tradition in my family. The crust is the best ever, to this day having lived in Chicago, NYC, and DC this is the best crust I've eaten it doesn't get...More
Although we get pizza every Friday for dinner, we hadn't ordered from Zamarelli's in several years and I forgot why so I decided to place an order. I was told it would be ready in 1.5 hours (Wow really, that's the longest wait I've heard...More