One of the best if not the best pizza I have ever ate 37th st it's wonderful definitely will be back
21 - 30 of 106 reviews
We get meatball subs to-go about once per week; they are that reliably good. I also enjoy their calzones and baked ziti with meat sauce. While this isn't my favorite pizza in town, they get our vote for the aforementioned items, open on Sundays, very...More
We were told about other pizza places in the area but not about this one. By chance, we found it and it is the best in the city of New Bern!! A little out of the way but the service, food and atmosphere is perfect!!
New Bern has it's fair share of Italian and pizza places. 37th Street by far is my favorite! I usually get carry out, so cannot comment on the facilities. Always ready when I get there. (Usually call in my order.)
We went for dinner and ordered beer, a pizza and salad. The beer was cold and quite reasonably priced. The salad was a huge hunk of iceberg lettuce that they didn't bother to break up. A few wedges of hard tomatoes and a couple slices...More
We have enjoyed the food and atmosphere at 37th Street for at least 35 years when they were in a different location. My favorite meal is meatballs with tomato sauce covered in Mozzarella cheese and baked in the oven, along with a fresh garden salad...More
We wanted Italian and this fit the bill. We ordered meatballs as an appetizer. It was served with a light crispy crust and soft center bread. My husband ordered Stromboli that was delicious. I ordered the stuffed shells and they were delicious with meat sauce....More