My sister's and I ate here while in Maggie Valley. One of them had the Prime Rib and after all of us tasting it we all agreed that this was the juiciest, best tasting, and most tender Prime Rib we had ever put in our...More
1 - 10 of 766 reviews
We had heard this was one of the best places to eat. Wait staff was amazing. The atmosphere charming. Then it went downhill quickly. I had the grilled prime rib.Thinnest prime rib ever. I think my knife was thicker. I ordered medium rare, it was...More
We were very disappointed with J. Arthur's, after being told that the steaks in particular were excellent. My husband and I both had prime rib and it wasn't the worst prime rib I've ever had but it wasn't particularly good. The salad was just lettuce...More
Old dirty carpeting. Dark atmosphere. Strange decor; Christmas, Swan/goose replicas, Moving trolley, Transportation memorabilia on the walls. Cheap vinyl table clothes. High priced entrees ($40 ribeye?). We had the dinner salads ($10) plus the smallest blackened chicken breast I have ever seen ($5) and extra...More
We always eat here when visiting the Maggie Valley and Cherokee areas. The food is consistently good and I love the rustic lodge feel. I had the grilled trout with tomato jam. It was outstanding. I had not tried this sauce before so I requested...More
J. Arthur's is a good steakhouse. The steaks were tender and flavorful and cooked correctly. The salad was crisp. The service warm and attentive. The owner came by to check on our meal and made us feel welcomed. The wine list is limited. but adequate....More
We are local residents. Have been disappointed in the past in quality of the food for the price. Family visiting for the 4th wanted to try it so we went again. The atmosphere is pleasant and the place is clean, but prices do not reflect...More
Darrell So sorry to hear that you weren't delighted with our food and service as that is our goal with every customer and we try very hard to make everyone happy. We've had very fine reviews lately so wish you had said something while you...More
Great food and service! My husband has the ribs and it was a huge rack for the price! Great place to eat with children!
Thanks so much for your excellent review. We are most appreciative and hope to see you again in the future!!
I ordered the steak. It was ok but it wasn't worth $24.00. I had to 10 ounce NY Strip. Potatoes tasted like instant ones.Atmosphere was nice however and wait staff were good. My wife did say the pork chop was very good.More
Ooh Craig. Sorry to hear you weren't wowed as we expect our customers to be. Never remember a complaint about our homemade potatoes and have them all the time so will check into it. Next time just let us know as we make all mistakes...More
To begin with, J. Arthur's is among the nicer longer establishments in the Valley. Granted appearances can be decieving (both good and bad) but the point being that curb appeal can get you to stop, and in our case it did. The Hostess, a charming...More
Thank you for your very detailed review which we will have our chef read as well. We're so happy you enjoyed and when in Florida do visit our Maneros in Palm City as well!!