Nice lil cafe.. Great place to stop in if your on this side of the island...Clean and quiant little cafe.
1 - 10 of 1,015 reviews
Read reviews and was excited to try it out. Turned out the food was uninspired. It was okay but did not live up to the reviews I read. The crab cake appetizer was dull ... it needed more crab meat , chunks of blue crab......More
I am sincerely sorry you didn't enjoy your dinners at the cafe. We use fresh crabmeat in our crab cakes and very little filler. The Filet Coquille is made to order so I am sorry you thought the sauces were the same. One was a...More
This place is great. So glad we finally came. Charming house converted to a restaurant. Very accommodating with seating and menu. Good was some of the best, while dining out, we've ever had. Service was so nice and attentive but not pushy. Great for date...More
Thank you so much for writing about the Colington Cafe. We love for our customers to enjoy themselves. With this being one of our last nights of our 29th season, it still warms my heart to have our customers enjoy the service and the fresh...More
Quaint,casual and not pretentious at all. Excellent food at a fair price,service is efficient and friendly.We try to dine there whenever we are on OBX.More
Thank you so much for your review on The Colington Cafe. We sure do appreciate you taking out the time, but thank you for mentioning we are not pretentious. We were described as that and it broke my heart. We all love our customers so...More
Wonderful return visit to The Colington Café for my parents wedding anniversary. Once again exceptional service and food and such a beautiful location. This really is a special place and my family & I highly recommend it. Please check out this Outer Banks treasure.More
Thank you so much for sharing your experience and it makes me especially happy to know you all celebrated your parent's wedding anniversary. Our staff loves to add to special memories. We try hard to make it special for each and every customer so thank...More
Seems like the place to go for a gourmet meal. Southern service. Ambiance is an old house. Go check it out.
I am so glad you enjoyed your time at The Colington Cafe. We really appreciate you taking out the time to share with others. Happy Holidays.
I took college friends there recently while gathering for a reunion. We hadn't been there in probably over 10 years... each of us was very happy with our meal. The service was super and we will definitely return. We were also happy with the pricing......More
Thank you so much for your review. It means so much to us, especially when we hear about reunions that make them even better. We really appreciate it.
As others have stated the pretentiousness here is in fact real. This establishment seems to be making do on reputation and regulars. I can't rate the food because I've never tried it and I no longer wish to. If the service is any reflection of...More
Dear Sir, We are so sorry about your experience but to be honest with you, you are the most vindictive customer we have had in 30 years. You failed to mention your reservation was at 7:30 and you stormed out at 7:28. My gracious daughter...More
We have been coming to the Outer Banks every year (more than once a year) since 1994. We just discovered this hidden gem on our latest trip in Nov of 2017. It is a charming, family run place that caters to their guests. Food was...More
Thank you so much for taking out the time to write a review on Trip Advisor. I know others appreciate it too. I am so glad you enjoyed your meal and I am so sorry that everything was piping hot. Our entrees are made to...More
Colington Cafe is tucked away off the beaten path but worth the search. The atmosphere, menu, and wait staff make eating there a pleasure. We have gone for years and do not feel our trip to the Outer Banks is really complete without the Colington...More
Thank you so much for taking out the time to write on the Cafe. We really appreciate it. It is so nice that we are a special part of your trip to the Outer Banks. We all love and appreciate our customers so much.. Thanks...More