The ice cream was delicious! Very creamy and flavorful. We will stop again on our next visit to the Outer Banks!
81 - 90 of 371 reviews
Pizza was quite tasty, BUT we had to wait an hour and 15 minutes to get our order after we were told it would be ready in 25 minutes. Be sure to allow plenty of time to get your order, even if you call it...More
We heard good things about American Pie's ice cream so we decided to make a trip one night while in Nags head. I got the peach ice cream and it was good but not better than any other hand scooped ice cream shop. I wouldn't...More
This was our first trip to the Outer Banks. On the last night of our stay, our children requested that we order pizza and have it delivered to our hotel. Well, we called American Pie and boy we are sure glad we did. This was...More
I love pizza... like, really love pizza. I eat pizza everywhere I go, from NC, to NYC, to Denver, to TX, to CA, and so on. Anywhere... any time... pizza. American Pie is some great pizza. Get it. Eat it. Nom nom... beach.
Friendly service from staff. Pizza was average as far as taste. Soft crust and our cheese slid off each slice:( definitely not what's suppose to happen. We did order wings, they were delicious. A little crispy and great flavor. Staff was kind enough to pack...More
This is the best pizza we have had at the Outer Banks bar none. We tried a basic cheese pizza. The crust was brushed with garlic and the cheese was plentiful. We received friendly courteous service. This was our first trip to American Pie. I...More
Cute place in the center of everything with good pizza and even better ice cream! The ice cream is home made and delicious! Do yourself a favor and get the chocolate peanut butter ice cream!
We got ice cream there twice, and finally tried their pizza on our last night in the area. I really liked it, though just be aware they really pile on the cheese. I would avoid getting extra cheese, doesn't seem necessary.