Quick and convenient, lots of choices to order by the slice. Nice, thin crust. Friendly staff. Popular with kids and adults alike.
1 - 10 of 61 reviews
New York Pizzeria brings the ONLY NY style and TRUE taste of pizza (I mean it) and to this magical little Town I now call home Trumansburg Ny! The staff and owner are always so nice I’ve never had a bad anything here! It’s NY...More
We order pizza from NY Pizzeria regularly and the quality is consistently good. The staff is friendly, the place is always clean, and the pizza is delicious! Whether we want it plain, or all dressed up, we have never been disappointed.
Order a full pizza or a slice of about 10 to 15 pizzas, ready to reheat. All excellent food. Friendly staff.
On Main Street trumansburg an Italian pizza maker great variety and crispy and delicious.you want to taste all kinds of pizza.i like the Hawaiian but also the vegetables is nice.hard to choose.also Italian soda to go with.
Used out trusty Tripadvisor app to find a place close to the falls for dinner. Easily found this lovely Pizzeria which was obviously one of the most popular places in town. We had to wait about 40 minutes for our pie, but the pizza did...More
This is a nice little Pizzeria for a very small town. Our pizza was as good or better than any big city Pizzeria. The only thing that would have made it better would have been a cold beer.
Driving through town on my way to Ithaca and wanted a slice or two to hold me over for dinner. Living in NYC I don't consider myself a Pizza Snob, but I do like good pizza. These guys deliver. Thin crispy crust with great sauce...More
Don't ignore this little pizzeria. It's not much from the outside, but they have some of the best pizza in the state, and I'm fully aware this is a big claim to throw down. I'm in NYC twice a month and always grab pizza here....
Trumansburg is a very small town with a great pizza place! I grew up in the Philly area, the pizza at New York Pizzeria will hold its own in NYC or Philly! Go grab a slice for lunch or order a pie for dinner and...More