Absolutely the best Italian food on the east end. It is a staple for our family and we have never had anything but awesome food, service, and a great atmosphere. Thank you all. Merry Christmas
Absolutely the best Italian food on the east end. It is a staple for our family and we have never had anything but awesome food, service, and a great atmosphere. Thank you all. Merry Christmas
Was at micaelangelos on a saturday night and instantly felt at home. We had a terrible experience earlier at another restaurant earlier and had left and michaelangelos saved our night. The comfortable seating great service and reasonable prices will make me come back anytime i...am in the northfork guaranteed.More
A true resource in the area. Not only for dining inside or on the front patio, but the takeout volume here is amazing. The menu is extensive, the quality is very good and consistently so. The prices continue to be reasonable. Recommended.
We have been coming to this place for years. It has been a keeper. The food is always excellent. The staff has gotten a bit inexperienced recently and that may just be the difficulty in getting help. Tonight we had an incident that was very...surprising. We ordered our dinner and after a few minutes we realized the waitress did not ask us what type of pasta we wanted. The waitress will always ask what type of pasta you want with your dinner. Not sure why our waitress forgot to ask. We called her over and let her know we were not asked about pasta. The answer we got was "well when customers don't ask, we will serve pasta and red sauce. We let her know we do not like pasta and red sauce. She came back and told us bit was too late to change. This is a terrible answer. Can you seriously tell me that throwing red sauce on pasta is something that can't be undone??? So you are willing to disappoint a customer for the unwillingness to replace a 5 cent pasta side dish?? This isn't our normal experience. We love this reataurant but this particular behavior has made us reconsider returning as often.More
Pretty damn good. Honest, bold, and full of impact. If you miss a nice old fashion tactile menu, this is the place. Options to the moon, cravings for the soul.
I have always liked and frequent this restaurant. The only issue I have with the place is they keep pizza out unprotected. Most of the pizza is kept behind glass but they also put pizza on top of the glass where customers talk over that...counter. I hope some one from there reads this and realizes no pizza should be exposed like that. Now more then everMore
Consistently good quality Italian food. Good for lunch or dinner anytime. Had the chicken parmesan and spaghetti and meatballs
The Original Michelangelo Pizzeria is by far and away the BEST Italian restaurant on the East End of the Island. . Every time we travel to Southold, The Original Michelangelo Pizzeria is our first stop. Don't be fooled by "Pizzeria". The pizza is fabulous ,...but the dfinner's are beyond belief !!! The only problem, there are so many delectable selections on the dinner menu , it's hard to choose. The staff makes you feel like family and the portions are Big. Loving Italian food as I do, this place is "to die for" HIGHLY RECOMMENDED !!!More
The kitchen was overwhelmed when we arrived. The waitress suggested we order pizza since it would be prepared by the other kitchen in the pizza parlor. The pizza was was very good. We were disappointed we could not try the dinners.
When you’ve spent the day on the beach, this is ok for take out. Just don’t expect great pizza. Call early as the take out business is brisk given that competition is limited.
Hometown pizza place, nothing special. Seems to be understaffed at times so be prepared to wait a bit for your food. Guessing a lot of the dishes are pre-prepared as one of our entrees was cool in the center. Good for a slice or two...for lunch; dinner should be shared somewhere else.More
Just got home from Michelangelo’s it is way over priced. Frozen food?? Waitstaff disappears. Nearly 4 percent added if using credit or debit ?? Won’t recommend this place to anyone!!
service was really poor, from our server all the way to the kitchen.so was the food. we were seated immediately. it was not busy. However, it took over 1 hour to get our meal. 8 main dishes were ordered and 5 came out together. 15...minutes for the other 3. We complained, and asked for the manager. we wanted to eat together. Needless to say the dishes delivered first were luke warm when the other dishes finally.arrived. All the while we were asking to see the manager. I would have had better success asking to see the town mayor. One dish included basil, which was never brought to the table, even asking 5 times. My cesar salad was absolutly the worst I have ever experienced. It was delivered hot and the lettuce was soft/soggy/spoiled, and without the piece of salmon i asked for. never received the salmon even though i kept requesting it. they charged me for it, refused to take it off the bill for a good 5 minutes of trying to convince them it was never received. all the while, we asked for a manager. no one appeared. by this time, our waitress was no where to be found. the hostess brought our bill and the basil. On the way out, our host, who is a regular, saw the manager/owner and and asked why he would not come our table. his reponse - he was making pizza. at the end of that conversation, he suggested, that we go and make a bad review if we want. it dosent bother him either way. so, here is the review he requested. of course, we will never return. the sad part, he doesnt careMore
Was in town visiting and ordered from there three days in a row. Outstanding pizza!! We had the salad pizza, white cheese and broccoli, and plain cheese pizza. All were delicious and fresh. The cannolis looked incredible but didn’t try them....next time! Staff were friendly...and helpful. Highly recommended!More
Been there many times. The food is consistently good and the prices are reasonable. I particularly recommend the veal dishes. Portions are generous!