I highly recommend the chicken wing sub: amazing sauce and perfectly toasted. Plus everyone who works here is always super nice and patient when you can’t make your mind up. Thanks Valentine’s!!!!
1 - 10 of 51 reviews
Yuck. How can you go wrong with NY pizza? Order from this place. Sausage, spinach pizza literally had no taste. It is hard to understand how they can miss layering flavor? Worst pizza in NY. Disappointing.
This is Both a Deli with Sub's The Pizza will be as close as you get to a New York Style Pizza Thin Crust Home Made Dough and Pizza Sauce. Delicious I Recommend the Turkey Bacon Pesto Panini / or sub with Roasted Reds (...More
I love Valentine's big time and they have great people there and they always treat you like family and they always want you to come back time after time!!!!!!!!
We shared a few pizzas with friends and enjoyed them. I thought they could have used more spice so I would just say average.
Stayed just outside of town and ordered their pizza with our choice of toppings - quick friendly delivery and amazing amazing NY pizza! I'm still thinking about it!
We drove up to Skaneateles for the afternoon and started off with lunch at Valentines as the pizza had come highly recommended. It was okay, but nothing special. Flavors didn't jump out as we expected (and based upon the recommendation we received). In their defense...More
We stayed at the Packwood House, right next door. We watched the constant flow of traffic in and out of this place and it looked like a local favorite. On our 2nd night we had terrible storms predicted so we decided to get subs and...More
We were in the Skaneateles area and looking for a place to grab a quick bite. This place certainly delivered that! Quick, friendly, efficient service. We had a dozen wings and pizza. We received our lunch FAST and everything was good. Very reasonably priced considering...More