They have the best food in the area and the staff are very friendly. I come here all the time and am never disappointed. The food is amazing!!!
Is this restaurant good for dining on a budget?
Is this an Italian restaurant?
Is this a pizza restaurant?
Does this restaurant have tables with seating?
Is this restaurant wheelchair accessible?
Is this a fast food place?
Is this restaurant appropriate for Kids?
Is this restaurant good for lunch?
Is this restaurant good for dinner?
Is this restaurant good for brunch?
Thanks for helping!Share another experience before you go.
I want to put this out there for everybody to hear. Sherrill New York pizzeria is under new ownership. They are the biggest group of douche bags I have ever had to deal with. I have ordered from them approximately five or six times in the last six months. After the new owners took over the restaurant. Each and every... More
Best place to grab some lunch they always have the best variety of pizza hot and ready and the prices are great !! The cheese slice pie is the BOMB!! The Garlic pizza is my favorite !!
Nice folks, great food! Ordered a Calzone with broccoli. It was hot, large, great crispy dough and delicious filling.
This was the last place on my list that I wanted to try while in the area. Great little family owned joint. Had a chance to meet the owner and she gave me some background on the place. At one time it was a bar, then became a pizzeria decades ago and then they bought it over 12 years ago.... More
The building looks outdated, so I went in there with low expectations, but I was pleasantly surprised! Very nice and clean place, bathrooms are the cleanest I've ever seen in a pizzeria. Staff was friendly and quick to serve us. Pizza was a thin crust pizza and the whole family loved it. Wings were different than what I'm used to,... More
If you're in the Sherrill, NY area, there is no better place for pizza than NY Pizza....it is on the north side of Route 5.....their pizza is as good as any from NYC!
Great Simple pizza picked up for a quick lunch. Sure they have plenty to choose from I just took what was readily available to satisfy the hungry.
The concierge at our hotel recommended this place and he was right! The size of the subs will blow you away. I swear we both order cold subs and went for large ($1 more than small - duhh) and it was as big as a loaf of italian bread....i am NOT kidding. I also ordered salad thinking that would round... More