We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Ratings and reviews

RATINGS
Food
Service
Value
Atmosphere

Details

CUISINES
Italian
Meals
Lunch, Dinner
FEATURES
Delivery
Reviews (18)
Filter reviews
18 results
Traveller rating
5
8
3
1
1
Traveller type
Time of year
LanguageEnglish
Traveller rating
5
8
3
1
1
Show reviews that mention
All reviews pinwheels seafood salad pizza brooklyn dishes neighborhood
Selected filters
FilterEnglish
Updating list...
Reviewed 24 March 2020

We were very fond of Plum Tomatoes, so we were wary when La Sorrentina, a restaurant in Brooklyn, took over. But after three visits we were won over. The old pinwheels and pizza are still there, but the parmigiana dishes, seafood salad, gnocchi with pesto,...and other pastas are even better. Only the wine has gotten pricey. The dining room is elegant now with tablecloths. Only a couple of tables are for no table service, unlike before. Although all restaurants are closed, they still offer takeout. I encourage people to help out by ordering from them. They will be glad they did.More

Date of visit: March 2020
Helpful?2  
Reviewed 27 January 2020 via mobile

Pizza is good. Wish they delivered it to my neighborhood. If I'm going that way home, I'll pick up a pie.

Date of visit: February 2019
Helpful?1  
Reviewed 8 April 2019

I recently had a meal there with a friend and it was very nice. Very good service, clean and very pretty place. The young man who waited on us on top of his game, nice respectful and attentive. We even got to meet his Dad...that evening and passed on the good news to him about his son. I will be going there to eat again soon!More

Date of visit: March 2019
Helpful?
Reviewed 6 April 2019 via mobile

Raw pizza. Bacon on it during a lent Friday which is why I order pizza on Fridays. $27 and they refused to refund or send me a proper order. I had to spend another $30 on dinner for my family. Last time I ordered a...hero, I found a fingernail and they assured me the worker was let go and my orders would be satisfactory going forward.More

Date of visit: April 2019
Helpful?
Reviewed 25 December 2018

Everyone comes here to take out a pizza. But if people sat in the pleasant dining room, they would discover free bruschetta and rolls, good red wines, great salads, and especially veal parmigiana, pepperoni pinwheels (best ever), puttanesca, seafood salad, and many other made-to-order Italian...dishes. Yes, it looks sort of mall-like Italian kitsch. But that’s part of the fun. The service is young and earnest. Yes, the pizza is good, but having it here is even better.More

Date of visit: August 2018
Helpful?
Reviewed 31 January 2018 via mobile

Locals are often divided on this place but more because of service and attitude as the food is very, very good. Various pizza options are excellent, family favorites include grandma, buffalo chicken, and margarita. Dishes can be good to excellent with regulars (chicken parm, eggplant...parm, spaghetti), all better than average with good portions. Some creative options are very good including roasted chicken corn salad, capellini arrabiata, and grilled seafood salad. Issues with delivery, staff attitude (kid servers are nice but not experienced) and credit card mistakes. There are other options in the area but if food is the only consideration, this is a good place to eat.More

Date of visit: December 2017
Helpful?
Reviewed 13 September 2017 via mobile

A real neighborhood standout! They do deliver but dining at Plum Tomatoes is just fine...white tablecloths and wait staff do justice to the restaurant. The spaghetti marinara and dishes with clam sauce are excellent. For coffee and dessert go across the street to the bakery.

Date of visit: September 2017
Helpful?
Reviewed 17 June 2017 via mobile

Ordered the special, lobster ravioli.. lobster pcs were overlooked, rubbery and small... There's nothing that is unfixable about this restaurant, just like there really isn't any reason to go back..

Date of visit: June 2017
Helpful?
Reviewed 14 February 2017

The pizza is good. A nice variety of different style of topping and the best ever garden salads. I like it with grilled chicken . Its enough to feed two people easily.

Date of visit: July 2016
Helpful?
Reviewed 9 November 2016

Listen to the locals.... Avoid this restaurant. Poorly run, rude owners and lousy service. Much better pizza all around town.

Date of visit: July 2016
Helpful?
View more reviews
Best nearby
Best nearby hotelsSee all
The Rockaway Hotel
102 reviews
1.67 km away
La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Far Rockaway -Beach Hotel
117 reviews
6.47 km away
Comfort Inn Brooklyn
71 reviews
7.07 km away
Best Western Plus Brooklyn Bay Hotel
360 reviews
7.57 km away
Best nearby restaurantsSee all
PICO Kitchen & Cantina
71 reviews
.02 km away
Belle Harbor Steak House
82 reviews
1.01 km away
Wharf Bar & Grill
44 reviews
1.01 km away
Cuisine By Claudette
48 reviews
1.04 km away
Best nearby attractionsSee all
A-Team Paddleboarding
10 reviews
.75 km away
American Princess Cruises - Day Cruises
48 reviews
3.08 km away
Rockaway Beach
210 reviews
3.09 km away
Yacht Rock Charters
22 reviews
2.94 km away
Is This Your Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.
Claim Your Free Listing
Frequently Asked Questions about Plum Tomatoes

Yes, Plum Tomatoes offers delivery services.

Plum Tomatoes is rated accordingly in the following categories by Tripadvisor travellers:
  • Food: 4.5
  • Service: 4.5
  • Value: 4.5
  • Atmosphere: 4