The location in Riverhead has closed. The location in Amagansett is still open. If you're looking for a seafood place in Riverhead try buoy one. It's another great choice with some outdoor seating.
1 - 10 of 165 reviews
My husband and I drove past this place so many times before we finally decided to stop and try it. After our first visit, we were hooked and now it's become a tradition. We always make a point of stopping here when we're visiting the...More
It's good. Definitely not the greatest, but if it's a good lobster roll your looking for, like we were, it's worth the drive. We drove an hour round trip from the Hamptons. Best not forget the local to this area, farm stands with their great...More
The fish and chips were exactly what I was looking for. The lobster roll is traditional, shredded lobster meat and mayo, nothing fancy. Great if that's what you're looking for. A little pricier, but it's New York. Go see Danny out back at the Tasting...More
Stopped for an early dinner while out in Riverhead. Have visited the Amagansett location many times but never been here before. Very quiet at five when we arrived but cars were arriving as we finished. We chose to eat outside on the covered patio which...More
Was told it was a good place to eat, was not dissapointed. Ordered the house special "Lobster Roll" of which I've had many, but none as good as this one. Others in my party enjoyed their meals as much as I did.
I only have good things to say about this restaurant I was in the area with my family and we had the soup, cold lobster salad, warm lobster and we were so pleased Great service A real throwback regarding the decor Warm and friendly Traditional...More