Prime 289 closed six months ago. It is my understanding that Toscano's is either moving to this location or making a second location on where Prime 289 was.

Only open a few days so the prices were so high to make up for it. Food was great. My daughter attending school there doesn't want to go there anymore because its just too expensive

Prime 289 is closed! Rumor has it that a new steakhouse is going in here shortly. This placed filled an important niche in Oneonta. Hope springs eternal for a worthy replacement!

When I left this restaurant my comment was "that was the best rib eye I have ever had". The service was super. Our waiter was superb. Everything from bread, salad, entrée was excellent. I even told our waiter that the steak was so good. He...More

Took my daughter who is a student at SUNY Oneonta here. Great choice. Nice ambience inside, and the food was great! The calamari appetizer was so tender. And my salmon melted in my mouth. The mashed potatoes and vegetable medley were also excellent. Highly recommend.

Décor is nice with the leather seating and brick walls. Food was good....had a very tasty buffalo chicken and spinach soup. Had a Porterhouse....was good but I grill better steaks all the time and it was ordered Med Rare and came out way rare. Was...More

Just Ok place. It has some rave reviews. But I am more the chef Ramsey type. Took the family, they are not family friendly. Ordered the Porterhouse, medium. came out mooing. Not a great cut of meat, just OK. Wife ordered the pork, it was...More

Wow I have been waiting a while to come to this restaurant . It has a great atmosphere very romantic for couples . We were celebrating made reservations the day before Saturday early evening, between 4 and 6is half price appetizer's and 5$ house wine...More

If you plan on lodging in Oneonta, NY while visiting The Baseball Hall of Hame, Prime 289 is a "hands on" absolute must. It definitely has the most enchanting atmosphere in Oneonta, NY. Had the most mouthwatering clams as a starter, and devoured perhaps the...More

We waited 3 days for this restaurant to open as it's closed Sun-Tues but worth wait. They have a great happy hour with good $3.00 wines and buy one get 2nd appetizer half off. We sat down to dinner afterwards and had the Delmonico Steak,...More