We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Ship Lantern Inn has been an "institution in our area for at least 3 generations. It has excellent cuisine, superior service and always a pleasant greeting. The atmosphere is delightful and comfortable. Prices are reasonable for the menu.
This place is top notch! Food was amazing, delicious, served hot and plentiful. The service was BEYOND amazing! My drink was never empty, we never had to ask for anything, and the waitstaff was pleasant and accommodating. I had the filet mignon, and my husband...More
We celebrated New Year’s Eve at the ships lantern and we were not disappointed. The food was delicious, the wait staff friendly and the prices of the meals very reasonable. They have complete meal specials during the week and if you are in the area...More
The restaurant is very high-priced. They boast Continental cuisine which I’m not sure is the selling point. The food is very rich, they give you vegetables but a tiny portion, heavy on the meat, heavy on the fat, heavy on the butter and light on...More
Salvatore the maitre d’ welcomed us and we immediately felt at home. You can really tell that this restaurant cares so much about its customers...all the staff are extremely attentive and nothing is too much trouble.
The food was delicious. The Caesar Salad for two...More
Just got back from dinner at the Ship Lantern Inn in Milton, NY. Dinner was great - servers were friendly, polite and helpful; courses were at just the right pacing; and the guitarist-singer was really good and just the right loudness so that we could...More
Was there for fundraising event. Passed food was good. Sit down buffet style food was wonderful. Sliced hot meats, lemon chicken, pasta platters, vegetables, etc. Very well prepared and well presented. Great setting and friendly staff. Never been there for dinner but the locals raved...More
First time there. Wonderful food and service. Super knowledgeable staff. The bartender came over to the table to check that the wives were happy with their drinks. My wife said it may have been the best martini she's had. Looking forward to going back.
My wife, 2 daughters and I celebrated one daughter's 50th birthday here on a Saturday night. I would say that reservations are a must, at least on a weekend.
My wife and one daughter chose the Saturday Night prix fixe menu so they started with...More
Our favorite restaurant. Always come back to celebrate our anniversary. Outstanding menu, superior service and outstanding food. Love the escargot appetizers and Chilean sea bass and liver & Onions. Will always go back and highly recommend to others.