Good basic pizza. Not a fancy restaurant, but good food and service. Run by a nice family from Greece.
1 - 10 of 10 reviews
Get your average frozen pizza, bake it in the oven. Remove the pizza, throw it in the trash. Eat the cardboard disc it came on. That's roughly the quality here.
Have cash to eat here. When you come to New York, you just expect amazing pizza. The pizza was ok, nothing to write home about. The inside was stuck in 1982 quite possibly and could really use a really good cleaning. Lackluster wait staff, but...More
Another dump in Highland Falls that relies on tourist! I live here mind you! Stay away. Nothing is fresh here. Quality is non- =existent! Pizza by name only!!
Service is fine, pizza is average. It's not that the pizza is awful, I compare it roughly the same as Mama Celeste or Elios. It tastes the same as frozen pizza from the grocery store. Not as good as Red Baron though.
The only place we went for pizza in the four years we lived here, after trying all their competitors. The pizza crust is the best I've ever tasted. I was recently here on a trip after being away for 17 years and it was exactly...More
I came here a little after lunchtime on a weekday. Right away it felt a bit strange. I know it was a slightly unorthodox hour crowd-wise but it was deadly silent in there and no one was around anywhere. Finally one older man came up...More
This is so far my favorite pizza place near WP. The owners care about the quality of their product. Don't expect a "hot and ready" pizza, it will take a minute to make. They only accept cash, but don't worry, there is a bank that...More
I'm a regular Friday night customer of Brothers Pizza and I go back again and again because I like their thin crust pizza. Tell Andy, the owner, or his wife Kelly, "Give me two slices, don't cut it. Add extra cheese, pepperoni, mushroom, onions and...More